When selecting a reliable dog training professional, it’s crucial to prioritize experience, education, and methodology. Look for trainers who use positive reinforcement techniques, as these have been shown to be the most effective and humane approach for modifying canine behavior and teaching new skills. Check for certifications from reputable organizations like the International Association of Canine Professionals (IACP), the Certification Council for Professional Dog Trainers (CCPDT), or the Karen Pryor Academy. Additionally, a formal apprenticeship with a qualified trainer or trainers can also be a valid and acceptable form of proof for a trainer’s credentials. These forms of education ensure that the trainer is well-versed in current best practices and adheres to ethical training standards. Ask for references or reviews from past clients to assess their reputation and success. If possible, observe a session or class to see how the trainer interacts with dogs and owners, ensuring they demonstrate patience, respect, and adaptability to each dog's needs. Finally, avoid trainers who rely on outdated dominance-based techniques, as these can damage the human-dog bond and lead to fear or aggression. They also do not address the root cause of the issue. A skilled trainer should focus on building trust and fostering a lifelong partnership between you and your dog.

Adopting a shelter dog or purchasing from a responsible, ethical breeder are both wonderful options for adding a new dog to your family. The most critical factor in this decision is ensuring that the dog’s personality and traits are a good match for the home. This compatibility reduces the likelihood of the dog being returned to a shelter or rehomed, which can be a traumatic experience for the animal. While some families may embrace the challenge of rehabilitating a rescue dog, others may not be equipped to handle the unpredictability or potential baggage that can accompany a shelter pet — and that’s okay. Ethical breeders still play an essential role by not contributing to shelter populations; they always maintain a commitment to taking back their dogs if an owner can no longer care for them. Ultimately, the most important thing is that a dog finds a loving, permanent home, whether it starts its journey in a shelter or with an ethical breeder. 

That being said, it’s important to acknowledge the existence of puppy mills and backyard breeders, whose practices harm dogs and perpetuate the cycle of overpopulation and abandonment. These breeders prioritize profit over the well-being of their animals, often neglecting proper health testing, humane living conditions, and responsible placement of their dogs. Supporting such operations directly contributes to the challenges faced by overcrowded shelters. It’s crucial for potential dog owners to do thorough research and ensure they are making ethical choices when adopting a dog, as every decision impacts the welfare of the dogs and the broader canine community. While rescues generally work toward a positive mission, it is also possible for them to become mismanaged, with some escalating into hoarding-level situations or misusing funds. Though these instances are far less common than the widespread issues caused by backyard breeders and puppy mills, they underscore the importance of vetting any organization—whether a breeder or rescue—before acquiring a pet. Making informed, ethical choices ensures the best outcome for both the animal and its future family.  

The use of treats and rewards in dog training is deeply rooted in established psychological principles, particularly the concepts of operant conditioning and classical conditioning. Operant conditioning, introduced by B.F. Skinner, is the foundation of reward-based training. Skinner's experiments with animals demonstrated that behaviors followed by positive reinforcement (e.g., food, praise, or play) are more likely to be repeated. Similarly, undesirable behaviors can diminish when they are not rewarded, a concept known as extinction. These principles apply universally, including to dog training.

In Skinner's studies, animals pressed levers or performed tasks more consistently when reinforced with rewards. This highlights a crucial aspect of learning: behavior must be reinforced to persist. For dogs, this reinforcement often takes the form of treats, toys, or praise—elements that create positive associations with specific actions. The reward signals to the dog that they’ve made the correct choice, encouraging them to repeat the behavior in the future.

Further expanding on these ideas, Ivan Pavlov's work in classical conditioning also applies. Pavlov’s experiments with dogs demonstrated how associations could form between a neutral stimulus (like a bell) and a meaningful one (food). In training, this principle is evident when clickers are paired with treats, creating a clear and predictable marker for success. The clicker or verbal praise becomes a secondary reinforcer, motivating the dog even when food is phased out later.

Modern behavioral science has built upon these foundational ideas with additional research. Edward Thorndike's Law of Effect states that behaviors leading to positive outcomes are more likely to recur, while those leading to negative outcomes are less likely to happen. This principle underscores why rewards work better than punishment. While punishment can suppress behavior temporarily, it often leads to negative side effects, such as fear, aggression, or stress, as shown in studies by psychologists like Karen Pryor, who helped pioneer clicker training and positive reinforcement.

The benefits of reward-based training extend beyond immediate behavior shaping. Training with rewards taps into the dog’s natural desire to engage in activities that benefit them, fostering a more collaborative and trusting relationship between dog and handler. Dogs are not inherently motivated to please humans; their behavior is driven by innate and learned motivations, which vary among breeds and individuals. For example, Border Collies may be motivated by movement and interaction, while Labrador Retrievers often find food highly rewarding. This aligns with research by Dr. John Paul Scott and John L. Fuller, who studied breed-specific behaviors and highlighted the importance of understanding individual and genetic predispositions in training. Their book, "

Genetics and the Social Behaviour of the Dog "  is considered the single most important and comprehensive reference work on the behavior of dogs ever compiled.

Ultimately, reward-based training respects the dog's intelligence and autonomy, creating an environment where learning is enjoyable and productive. Expecting them to work "for free" without any acknowledgment or incentive is both unrealistic and unfair. Whether it’s treats, toys, or verbal praise, providing some form of positive reinforcement is essential to maintain their focus, engagement, and willingness to learn. Without rewards, training can lead to frustration, decreased enthusiasm, and a breakdown in the trust and bond between dog and handler, ultimately undermining the success of the training process.

Attempts to train without rewards often fail to account for the psychological principles behind dog training, and can lead to frustration for both the dog and handler. Finding out what motivates your dog and using those rewards builds a foundation of trust and cooperation, ensuring long-term success and a happier, well-adjusted canine companion.

Successful dog training relies on the use of tools that encourage desired behaviors through rewards rather than punishments. One of the most popular tools is the clicker, which is used in clicker training. 

Clicker training is a popular method used to teach animals new behaviors by using a distinct sound, often produced by a small handheld device, followed by a reward.  The click serves as a positive reinforcement signal, marking the exact moment the animal performs the desired action, which helps them make a clear connection between the behavior and the reward. This technique is rooted in principles of operant conditioning, a form of learning where behaviors are modified by consequences. For animals, this method taps into the natural process of reinforcement learning, encouraging repetition of desired actions. Similarly, human psychology shares this principle through reinforcement theory, where behaviors are shaped by rewards or punishments.  

  1. Understand the Basics of Clicker Training

Before you begin, it's important to understand how clicker training works. First, a sound made by the clicker is used to mark the exact moment an animal performs a desired behavior. After the click, a treat or reward is immediately offered. This strengthens the association between the behavior and the reward. Eventually, the animal will associate the sound with being rewarded or doing a good job. This prevents the need to interrupt training sessions to receive a treat every time an action is performed, and also helps animals grasp new behaviors faster as they are given a clear and concise signal when they perform an action correctly.

Think of this similarly to playing the "Hot and Cold" Game with a child. It would become confusing and frustrating for them if you only ever told them when they were "Getting Colder", and they may never solve the puzzle. But by being able to convey both "Hot" and "Cold" emotions, the child is able to locate the target much faster, and the learning process stays fun and lighthearted.  By adding the clicker to a training session, you are adding the "Hot" or "Yes" signal and making things easier for your animal to understand. 

2. Introduce the Clicker to Your Animal

The first step is to familiarize your animal with the clicker sound. The goal is for the animal to associate the click sound with something positive.

Take a treat in one hand, and the Clicker in the other. Allow the animal to investigate the treat, but not interact with it. As soon as you open your hand, click and immediately offer a treat to your animal. Repeat this several times (about 10-15 clicks in a row), ensuring that the animal understands that the sound is linked to receiving a reward. 

Your animal should start to recognize the click as a signal for something good. Once they are comfortable with the sound, you're ready to start shaping behaviors. 

3. Define the Desired Behavior

Before using the clicker, think about what specific behavior you want to shape. 

Break down the behavior into small steps (also known as successive approximations). This will make it easier for the animal to learn gradually.

For example, if you're teaching a dog to sit, the final behavior is the dog sitting down, but you may first reward the dog for lowering its bottom toward the ground, then for staying there longer, and finally for sitting all the way down.

4. Start with Luring or Capturing the Behavior

There are two main techniques to shape a behavior using clicker training:

Luring: Use a treat to guide your animal into the position or action you want. For example, holding a treat above your dog's nose and move it backward, encouraging them to sit.
Capturing: Wait for the animal to naturally perform the desired behavior and click when it happens. For instance, if you're teaching a cat to lie down, you might wait until they naturally lie down and click at that moment.

5. Use the Clicker to Mark the Behavior

As soon as the animal performs the desired action (even a small part of it), click and immediately follow up with a reward. Timing is crucial—make sure the click happens at the exact moment the animal performs the action to make the connection clear. If you feel as though you may have missed the timing or the animal has already clearly moved on to a new behavior before you were able to click, move on without clicking and wait for the next opportunity to mark the behavior. It is best to miss a single mark than to possibly create confusion for the animal or unintentionally capture the wrong behavior. 

6. Shaping Through Successive Approximations

As the animal starts understanding the behavior, you can begin to shape it further by rewarding smaller steps leading toward the full behavior.

Gradually increase the criteria for the behavior. For example, when teaching a dog to fetch, you might first click when the dog picks up the ball, then for bringing it closer to you, and finally for handing it over completely.

By reinforcing each successive step, you build up to the final behavior.

7. Generalizing the Behavior

Once the animal reliably performs the behavior in one context (e.g., sitting when asked at home), it’s time to start generalizing. This means teaching the animal to perform the same behavior in different locations, under different conditions, and with varying distractions.

Practice in different rooms, outdoors, with other people around, or try varying the distance between you and the animal, or practicing in new environments like pet friendly stores. Training in as many situations as possible will help strengthen the reliability of the command as well as providing much needed mental stimulation for the animal. 

8. Introduce Verbal Cues or Signals

Once your animal is consistently performing the behavior with the clicker, you can introduce a verbal cue or hand signal to associate with the behavior.

Say the word or gesture just before you expect the behavior. Reward the animal when it responds correctly. Over time, the animal will learn to associate the verbal cue or signal with the behavior and respond without needing the clicker. 

Some animals may seem too small or "not intelligent enough" to learn vocal cues or hand signals, but they may surprise you! Animals as small as rats and mice have been known to learn hand signals and verbal commands for different behaviors! 

9. Fade Out the Clicker and Treats Gradually

As your animal masters the behavior, you can begin to reduce the frequency of the clicks and treats. This is known as fading:

Start by giving the treat intermittently (not every time). Gradually, you can phase out the clicker as well, using only verbal praise or a reward once in a while.

This makes the behavior more reliable and helps the animal learn that the behavior is expected even without constant reinforcement.

10. Be Patient and Consistent

Clicker training requires patience, repetition, and consistency. Animals learn at different paces, so be prepared to work at their speed. Short, frequent sessions are often more effective than long, sporadic ones. Try to end each session on a positive note to keep your animal motivated and engaged.

Extra Tips for Success:

Be clear and consistent: Use the same clicker sound and rewards to ensure your animal understands.

Keep sessions short: Aim for 5-10 minute sessions to keep your animal’s attention high and avoid frustration.

Stay positive: Always use positive reinforcement. Avoid punishment or negative methods, as these can make training less effective.

Have fun: Clicker training should be an enjoyable experience for both you and your animal.

With practice, you’ll find that clicker training can be a highly effective way to build a strong bond with your animal while teaching them a wide range of behaviors! 

In contrast, aversive tools like prong or shock collars are ineffective and can be harmful to the dog. These devices rely on causing discomfort or pain to deter undesired behaviors. Research has shown that using such tools can increase fear, anxiety, and aggression in dogs, which ultimately undermines the trust between dog and owner. These methods do not address the root cause of behavior issues and often result in temporary compliance at best. Positive reinforcement, on the other hand, encourages dogs to choose good behavior on their own and fosters a trusting, respectful relationship.

With practice, you’ll find that training can be a highly effective way to build a strong bond with your animal while teaching them a wide range of behaviors! Still have questions about training, or want some help getting started? Feel free to contact us below!   

Ready to take the next steps in learning how to better communicate with your companion? Follow the link below to learn about our rates and classes!